A Tip to Help Sensitive Writers: Dealing with Harse Criticism

Different opinions on negative criticism.

I have read several articles today from a few different writers about how to deal with negative criticism on their work. These articles were on different types of writing not just poems, short stories, books, but musicians as well. It seems by these articles, whether it is true or not, that females did not take negative criticism as well as some men did. This one male writer said that he learned from all negative criticism, and that maybe there was some hidden truth in some of the critique regardless of how harse it was. This could also be because men are more or less into competition, or are sports oriented. Let’s face it, many male musicians are not exactly the jock type. Some are of course, but as a rule guys in band practise in school are usually not football players. Maybe some writers are more sensitive than others. I don’t think it has as much to do with gender as it does with what a person wants to express. Some writers want to write as I do, to feel the words and express emotion. I should be clear though as I wrote in my previous article, harse criticism is not the proper way to critique someones work.

Anyway, one of the articles was about a woman who said she did not take negative criticism well at all, and internalized it. Women in general she said did this, and I can believe this being a woman as well. Though I am not as sensitive as I appear. My writing is a way for me to get in touch with a more sensitive side, that I keep to myself. My problem with negative criticism is that, it is not as much an attack on my character as an attack on the emotions, that I felt at the time that I wrote the piece. I feel that when I write a poem, or a story that, I have written something creative, and want to share it with friends in hopes that something that I had written resonates with them as well. So to keep this sensitivity to criticism at bay. I decided to use a trick that I learned in my creative writing classes. This tip was to keep your writing for over six months to a year, or even a month, then look over it, improve it, and then publish it. In other words, if a piece is personal, and hot off the press so to speak, hold it back for a while, so if by chance you get a harse comment it won’t offend you. Especially, if you are in a semi hostile writing group.

A man in another one of the articles that I read was talking about the Internet, as a hostile place that you have to get a “thick skin” to survive here. He talked about a musician on the Internet that pulled his Twitter account because of the hostile comments that he got on his music. This goes along with what the woman in her article said as well. That she felt her writing was her baby that she felt she gave birth to it. I have felt that way about a piece that I had written before, like it was my creation, which actually it is a brainchild that you birthed. So, holding your piece nurturing it, and holding it closely to you for awhile might not be a bad idea. If in fact, you still feel the connection to it emotionally. Then, let your brainchild leave the nest and flourish.

12
Liked it

Tags: , , , , , , ,

5 Responses to “A Tip to Help Sensitive Writers: Dealing with Harse Criticism”

  • mzmax100
    October 17th, 2009 at 3:15 am

    ooh I love this. Exactly the kind of words I need to write on. Thank you for sharing.

  • revivor
    October 17th, 2009 at 7:01 am

    I think there is a massive difference between negative and constructive criticism – for example I highly value your work and therefore point out that in the title it should be “harsh”. I say this so that others will not look and inwardly be critical but never say anything xx

  • CA Johnson
    October 17th, 2009 at 3:13 pm

    Thank you for sharing this idea. That might be a good idea to wait to publish your work. It will give you a chance to look back at it and see if it could make some changes to it.

  • Mystify
    October 17th, 2009 at 5:40 pm

    Some wonderful points here!I believe that by writing you are actually getting to know yourself, regardless of what anyone else says or thinks of it and eventually overtime you improve on the skill because you know yourself and your ability to write.Anything that is written by a writer has a message and that message can be interpreted in many different ways but the meaning is something the writer always holds they key to! Very thought provoking write cassandra,terrific work!

  • Dan Flowers
    October 23rd, 2009 at 1:57 pm

    Good article… I can be overly sensitive sometimes as a songwriter. I’ve had to learn tricks to break free from the trap so that I can move forward and out into the world. Otherwise my music, as well as other writings that I’ve done would be delegated to the realms of my personal hidden creations safe from the world at large because I’d keep them all to myself. I decided that I couldn’t do that, so now here I go again offering up my most precious things for the world’s consumption in hopes that they well be gentle and kind back to my music, and to me.

Leave a Reply

Click the icon to the left to subscribe to Writinghood with your favorite RSS reader.
© 2009 Writinghood | About | Advertise | Contact | Submit an Article
Powered by